While conducting research, you need to gather information from various sources. Locating suitable sources is essential to ensuring the quality of your research. This means that each source needs to be evaluated for its relevance, credibility, and reliability.
Different types of sources in research
- Primary sources: These provide firsthand evidence or an eyewitness account of information about a particular topic or event. They are raw data created at the time of the event or observation or later on through an eyewitness account. Examples include diaries, letters, photographs, speeches, works of art, government data, and statistics. Understanding these sources will equip you with a deeper understanding of your research topic, making you feel more knowledgeable and informed.
- Secondary sources: Sources that synthesize, analyze, and interpret primary sources are called secondary sources. They are written by a person who does not have a firsthand account or experience of the situation as it occurred. Thus, they are created after an event has happened. Examples include articles, books, reviews, etc.
- Tertiary sources: These sources provide a broad summary or overview of information collected from primary and secondary sources. Hence, they do not offer any original analysis. These are useful in obtaining context or background information on an event or topic. Examples include encyclopedias, dictionaries, and almanacs.
- Popular sources: These are written for a wide range of readers or the general public on various topics of interest. Newspapers, magazines, websites, and blogs are some examples of popular sources.
- Academic sources: Written by qualified researchers, academic sources are peer-reviewed and generally intended for a specific target audience comprising other researchers and experts in particular or related fields. Academic books and scholarly books are examples of academic sources.
- Government sources: These include information from government agencies, which can be local, state, or national. Reports, data, statistics, patents, and so on are examples of such sources.
- Web sources: This information is available online through websites, social media, podcasts, and so forth. Web sources are generally helpful in getting a preliminary understanding of new issues or topics.
Key factors to consider when evaluating sources
- Author: Who is the author, and are any credentials and institutional affiliations provided? Is the person known in the field, and has they been cited in other sources or references?
- Publisher: Is the publisher a known publishing company? Is it cited in other journals and reputed sources?
- Date of publication: It is important to note when the source was published to assess whether the information is current or obsolete for your study topic.
- Relevance: Is the source relevant and related to your topic of study?
- Objective reasoning: Is the information provided in the source well-researched and evidence-based? This is important because research should be based on sound evidence and logical reasoning. Does the information reflect bias or propaganda? This can be a sign that the source is not reliable. Is it objective and impartial? This is important because research should be unbiased and impartial, presenting the facts objectively without personal or political bias.
- Coverage: Does the work build on or update existing knowledge, or does it bring in new perspectives? This is important because research is a cumulative process, and you need to ensure that you’re building on the existing body of knowledge. Does it draw on primary or secondary sources or both? This will depend on the nature of your research and the type of sources you’re using. In the case of websites, make sure to additionally check whether the content of the source is original, borrowed or imported. This can help you assess the reliability and credibility of the information.
- Editions: Is this the first edition? New editions generally indicate that the work has been updated. For websites, note whether the last revision dates are provided.
There are some fundamental approaches that you can follow while evaluating sources.
The CRAAP Test
This is a framework that you can utilize to assess the credibility and reliability of sources. CRAAP stands for:
- Currency: Is the information provided in the source current or outdated? Does your research study require a current state of knowledge, or do you need to refer to historical information?
- Relevance: Is the content of the source relevant to your topic of study?
- Authority: Is the author and the publisher known in the field? What are the credentials of the author?
- Accuracy: Does the evidence support the arguments? Does the source present objective facts, or does it suggest bias or propaganda?
- Purpose: What is the purpose of the source? Is the information to teach, inform, entertain, or persuade?
Lateral Reading
Another approach to evaluating a source’s credibility. It involves comparing the source to multiple other sources, which helps validate evidence and identify gaps or weaknesses. By employing these strategies, you can feel confident in your ability to critically evaluate sources and ensure the integrity of your research.
Strategies for detecting potential biases
- Evaluate the source: Check the author and the publisher. Do they advocate a particular agenda, or are they biased?
- Inflammatory language: Is there the use of inflammatory language to overtly influence the views of the readers?
- Omissions and selective choosing of facts: Analyze whether only particular perspectives and information are selected, leaving out facts that contradict the author’s views.
- Verify facts: Are the facts presented objectively, or are they distorted or presented in an exaggerated language?
- Analyzing self-bias: Always be conscious of your biases and prejudices, which can colour your thinking about the information provided.
R Discovery is a literature search and research reading platform that accelerates your research discovery journey by keeping you updated on the latest, most relevant scholarly content. With 250M+ research articles sourced from trusted aggregators like CrossRef, Unpaywall, PubMed, PubMed Central, Open Alex and top publishing houses like Springer Nature, JAMA, IOP, Taylor & Francis, NEJM, BMJ, Karger, SAGE, Emerald Publishing and more, R Discovery puts a world of research at your fingertips.
Try R Discovery Prime FREE for 1 week or upgrade at just US$72 a year to access premium features that let you listen to research on the go, read in your language, collaborate with peers, auto sync with reference managers, and much more. Choose a simpler, smarter way to find and read research – Download the app and start your free 7-day trial today!
