9 Critical Reading Strategies and How it can Improve Your Writing

Reading, especially critical reading, is an integral aspect in the research process. However, research reading is not just about skimming through research papers, it is about engaging with the text and deriving the information presented to develop their own ideas. This makes it essential for PhD students and researchers to understand the importance of critical reading and cultivate the spirit of scientific enquiry early in the research journey. In fact, it’s well known that effective research reading and quality academic writing go hand in hand. The more you actively adopt critical reading strategies, the more you understand how best to present your work in research papers. But what is critical reading? And what critical reading strategies can you embrace to meaningfully connect literature reading with the research writing process? We aim to answer these common researcher questions in this article.

What is critical reading?

Critical reading involves actively reading the text to understand the author’s viewpoints, the aim of the research study, and how the results advance research in your field. Rather than blindly accepting what is stated in the text, you should examine and question assumptions in research papers and bring in your own experience and expertise to develop new ideas and fresh perspectives.

Critical reading goes a long way in transforming readers into creative researchers. Good critical reading skills also strengthen your ability to identify the strengths and weaknesses of past research in a specific field and highlight gaps in analysis or the literature itself. Ideas that emerge from this process help translate informed responses based on critical reading into future research studies that can advance science. It can also help you build strong theoretical foundations and improve the research design and methodology for your own work. Honing your critical reading skills allows you to easily assess evidence and integrate this information into your research writing.

Critical reading strategies for researchers

In this section we will discuss a few critical reading strategies that can aid researchers to fully comprehend and critically assess the content of literature they are reading. Listed below are some of the basic critical reading strategies that a researcher can adopt to make critical reading a habit.

1. Read with purpose: One of the most important critical reading strategies is reading research paper with a specific purpose or question in mind. Scan each section of the paper and highlight passages that address your specific purpose; this helps determine if the entire paper is worth reading. Over time, this helps speed up your critical reading skills so that you can quickly evaluate the relevance of a research paper. You will also be able to appreciate how high-impact research papers are structured and be able to translate this to your own writing.
2. Take down notes: It is important to underline key phrases and make notes when reading scholarly literature. Mark important observations and ideas and jot down your interpretations and any questions that arise from a close reading of the text. This critical reading strategy helps researchers derive the correct meaning and form intelligent arguments when writing research papers. Highlighting the most important and relevant parts of the text allows for more thorough reading and quick referencing later, which helps to speed up the overall academic writing process.
3. Read without biases: One of the most important critical reading strategies is having an open-minded approach. For instance, when reading specific scholarly articles you may come across perspectives and arguments that you strongly agree or disagree with. Here, it is essential to set aside personal beliefs and emotional reactions that may color your perspective or understanding of the research paper you are reading. Critical reading means being able to delve deeper and understand the arguments put forward by the author so that you can cite this correctly in your own writing.
4. Put things in context: When reading critically, researchers need to internalize the social, cultural, and historical context within which research has been conducted and written. To infer and derive meaning and take your own arguments forward, it is important to compare the situation in which the text was written to your present reality.
5. Look for connections: Part of the critical reading process is looking for connections between previously published papers in your field. Recognizing patterns and finding connections will help you build on existing knowledge, strengthen your research, and highlight how your work will contribute to your field of research. While seeking out related texts and sources also gives your research study and writing a more global perspective, you can also identify and connect with their authors to further your research learning.
6. Read multiple times: Researchers should read an article multiple times without distractions. Repeated critical reading with intent allows you to progressively understand more and draw connections you might have missed in the first round of generalized reading. While this may seem unnecessary, it’s important to understand that building a solid critical reading habit, just like academic writing, is a gradual process that takes time to perfect.
7. Maintain a journal: This step in critical reading involves jotting down important ideas, narratives and references, and areas of agreement or disagreement when reading research articles. Any question or doubt that may arise while reading research can also be noted down in this journal. Apart from creating a ready reference for the future, this is a great resource for when you are looking for ideas for future research projects.
8. Paraphrase and simplify: Critical reading helps to process complex technical information, but some portions of text may still stump readers. A great way to simplify these concepts is to paraphrase the writing. Rewriting the text in your own words without changing the essence of the text allows you to better comprehend the content of a research paper. This also helps to further strengthen your academic writing skills.
9. Build your vocabulary: When critically reading scientific literature, you may come across new words and phrases that are relevant to your field of research. Be sure to note these down so you can discover their meanings and the context within which they are used. Not only can this accelerate your critical reading over time, it will enrich the manuscript writing process by expanding your range of words.

Following these critical reading strategies can help you read more effectively and build a repository of great research ideas. Your learnings from and interpretations of previously published work can then be translated into potentially ground-breaking research that will put you on the path to success.

R Discovery is a literature search and research reading platform that accelerates your research discovery journey by keeping you updated on the latest, most relevant scholarly content. With 250M+ research articles sourced from trusted aggregators like CrossRef, Unpaywall, PubMed, PubMed Central, Open Alex and top publishing houses like Springer Nature, JAMA, IOP, Taylor & Francis, NEJM, BMJ, Karger, SAGE, Emerald Publishing and more, R Discovery puts a world of research at your fingertips. 

Try R Discovery Prime FREE for 1 week or upgrade at just US$72 a year to access premium features that let you listen to research on the go, read in your language, collaborate with peers, auto sync with reference managers, and much more. Choose a simpler, smarter way to find and read research – Download the app and start your free 7-day trial today!